Comparing 522 Uroe to the Tyrannical sword, here is what you get
Uroe:
+612 strength (with 2 sockets, could also socket 640 resilience or PVP power)
+1141 weapon damage
+ 773 mastery
+ 469 stamina
Tyrannical:
+ 841 resilience
+ 6195 PVP power
The resilience is clearly more valuable than 773 mastery and 469 stamina, but I don't think the PVP power can possibly outweigh 612 strength and 1141 weapon damage. The drop in obliterate and frost strike damage would be pretty significant, and I am not sure the increased surivability and disease damage can compensate for that. I can see the Tyrannical weapon being superior for unholy and DW, but 2hand is very reliant upon weapon damage. Also, my guild is close to having heroic Council down and the 535 weapon would only widen the gap.
Opinions? Almost capped on CP and don't want to buy the weapon and then regret it later.
Uroe:
+612 strength (with 2 sockets, could also socket 640 resilience or PVP power)
+1141 weapon damage
+ 773 mastery
+ 469 stamina
Tyrannical:
+ 841 resilience
+ 6195 PVP power
The resilience is clearly more valuable than 773 mastery and 469 stamina, but I don't think the PVP power can possibly outweigh 612 strength and 1141 weapon damage. The drop in obliterate and frost strike damage would be pretty significant, and I am not sure the increased surivability and disease damage can compensate for that. I can see the Tyrannical weapon being superior for unholy and DW, but 2hand is very reliant upon weapon damage. Also, my guild is close to having heroic Council down and the 535 weapon would only widen the gap.
Opinions? Almost capped on CP and don't want to buy the weapon and then regret it later.